Dare to Compare: Brown & Bronze Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils (Urban Decay, Rimmel, Too Faced, & NYX)

PURCHASED / AFFILIATE LINKS

NYX 16 Golden Bronze, Urban Decay Lucky, Urban Decay Bourbon, Urban Decay Corrupt, Urban Decay Stray Dog, Rimmel 211 Sable, Too Faced Perfect Brown, Urban Decay Demolition, & NYX 829 Hot Cocoa.

A cross section of different waterproof eyeliner in brown shades from both drugstore and high end lines. 

This one covers:
NYX Slide on Pencil $7.99US or $9.99 CAN  
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil $19US or $23CAN 
Rmmel Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer $5.99 or $78.99CAN 
Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner $18US or $24CAN 
NYX Slim Lip Liner Pencil $3.99US or $4.99 CAN

Products: 

Rmmel Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer is a soft formula waterproof twist up pencil.

NYX Slide on Pencil, cream and richly pigmented. The formula is also smooth to apply

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Pencil again a soft gel based product.

Too Faced Perfect Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner are buttery and richly pigmented.

NYX Slim Lip Liner Pencil although technically not an "eye pencil" this wax base formula work really well as a waterproof formula on the eye as we. It will need to be set to prevent smudging. 

Colour:

NYX 16 Golden Bronze & Urban Decay Lucky are very similar! Lucky is just a touch lighter and Golden Bronze is a touch richer red in tone.

Urban Decay Bourbon is a warm brown with gold shimmer. A reason for being a favourite shade from Urban Decay. 

Urban Decay Corrupt is just a darker version of Bourbon. This shade is a dupe to MAC Avenue Fluidline.

Urban Decay Stray Dog is a lovely taupe with a truer brown base, there not to many on the market sadly.

Rimmel 211 Sable, Too Faced Perfect Brown, Urban Decay Demolition are all matte warm browns. 

Too Faced Perfect Brown is the riches and most opaque in colour. 

NYX 829 Hot Cocoa is not a eyeliner but put this in for reference. It is a rich warn brown shade however.

Wear:

I get the same wear with all these brands actually 12+ hours on the eyes.

Removal:

The easiest to remove was the Rmmel Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer, it take litle effort with a makeup remover to remove. Because of the twist up design i don't think this has a as much silicon in it then the rest.

Packaging:

Rmmel Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer has a twist up design.

The rest are simple pencils that need to be sharpened. 

Swatched with one stroke and a block of colour each.

Daylight Swatches: NYX 16 Golden Bronze, Urban Decay Lucky, Urban Decay Bourbon, Urban Decay Corrupt, Urban Decay Stray Dog, Rimmel 211 Sable, Too Faced Perfect Brown, Urban Decay Demolition, & NYX 829 Hot Cocoa.

Flash swatches: NYX 16 Golden Bronze, Urban Decay Lucky, Urban Decay Bourbon, Urban Decay Corrupt, Urban Decay Stray Dog, Rimmel 211 Sable, Too Faced Perfect Brown, Urban Decay Demolition, & NYX 829 Hot Cocoa.

WINNER:

Really their all good so it's matter of picking your poison here. ;) For matte brown I really love Perfect Brown, for a rich metallic colour I'm very smitten with Golden Bronze.