COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch and Sunsets (w/ Too Faced Sweet Peach & Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance Dupes) : Swatches & Review

PURCHASED

COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch and Sunsets.

The COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palettes retails for $11.99US and $12.99CAN at Walmart for 0.23 oz of product. I got these at Zerhs 9.98CAN, I think I got them on sale. ;)  These 2 CoverGirl palettes pulled shades from the Too Faced Sweet Peach & Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance. But they are not dead on dupe (but certainly close enough!) to also warrant this Dare to Compare post again.

COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch and Sunsets.

COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch and Sunsets.

COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch and Sunsets ingredients.

Products:
These eyeshadows fall under 3 finishes matte/satin, satin/pearl, shimmer.

The matte shadows are very powdery, but the texture is smooth with a slight satin finish. Some of the shades can be slightly on the sheer side though.

The satin/pearls are closest to a pearl finish but subtler. The shades are finely milled, and the pigmentation is excellent, though a bit powdery.

The rest are the shimmer shades in these palettes, and none of them disappoints with some even being very pigmented and slightly powdery. None are really high shine either.

None of these shadows are chalky though. ;)

The COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch does have a sweet candy peach smell to it (like the Too Faced Sweet Peach)

Wear: On their own the last about 5-6 hours. A primer is needed for longer wear time.

Packaging: Is a simple, clear lid compact.

Colours:

Peach Punch shades in Peachy Keen, Peachini, Main Peach, Public Peach, Peach Sangria, Georgia Dreams, Grilled Peach, & Raspberry Peach.

Daylight swatches: Peachy Keen, Peachini, Main Peach, Public Peach, Peach Sangria, Georgia Dreams, Grilled Peach, & Raspberry Peach.

Flash Swatches: Peachy Keen, Peachini, Main Peach, Public Peach, Peach Sangria, Georgia Dreams, Grilled Peach, & Raspberry Peach.

Peachy Keen is a pale nude peach with a matte finish.

Peachini is a bright pink with a warm gold shimmer finish.

Main Peach is a deep warm brown with a matte finish.

Public Peach is a warm coral/peach with a matte finish. This shade is slightly sheer. 

Peach Sangria is a warm beige pink with a shimmer finish.

Georgia Dreams is a rust plum with a shimmer finish.

Grilled Peach is a warm brown with a shimmer finish.

Raspberry Peach is a is a rust brown with a matte finish.

Sunset shades in Aura, Afterlight, Sunup, Eventide, Dusk, Eve, Sundown, & Daybreak.

Daylight swatches: Aura, Afterlight, Sunup, Eventide, Dusk, Eve, Sundown, & Daybreak.

Flash Swatches: Aura, Afterlight, Sunup, Eventide, Dusk, Eve, Sundown, & Daybreak.

Aura is a cream with a satin/pearl finish.

Afterlight is a pink champagne with a shimmer finish.

Sunup is a pale gold with a shimmer finish.

Eventide is a rust red with a matte finish.

Dusk is a dusty brown with a shimmer finish.

Eve is a dusty red with a matte finish with purple/pink micro-shimmer.

Sundown is a bright plum with a matte finish.

Daybreak is a is a rust orange with a matte finish.

COMPARE:

COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Sunsets VS Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance in
Tempera, Golden Ochre, Vermeer, Buon Fresco, Antique Bronze, Love Letter, Cyprus Umber, Raw Sienna, Burnt Orange, Primavera, Red Ochre, Venetian Red, Warm Taupe, Realgar.

Daylight swatches: Aura, Tempera, Afterlight, Vermeer, Sunup, Primavera, Eventide, & Red Ochre.

Flash Swatches: Aura, Tempera, Afterlight, Vermeer, Sunup, Primavera, Eventide, & Red Ochre.

Daylight swatches: Dusk, Antique Bronze, Eve, Venetian Red, Sundown, Love Letter, Daybreak, & Realgar.

Flash Swatches: Dusk, Antique Bronze, Eve, Venetian Red, Sundown, Love Letter, Daybreak, & Realgar.

The Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance is one of the first berry tone palettes that came out the past 4 years. This COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Sunsets is definitely pulling shade from the ABH palette for sure!

Aura is deeper compared to Tempera.
Afterlight is darker compared to Vermeer.
Sunup is darker compared to Primavera.
Eventide is less red compared to Red Ochre.
Dusk is warmer less red compared to Antique Bronze.
Eve is warmer compared to Venetian Red.
Sundown is slightly darker compared to Love Letter.
Daybreak is warmer less orange compared to Realgar.

 COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch VS Too Faced Sweet Peach.

Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette in

White Peach, Luscious, Just Peachy, Bless Her Heart, Tempting, & Charmed I'm Sure.

Nectar, Cobbler, Candied Peach, Bellini, Peach Pit, & Delectable.

Peaches 'n Cream, Georgia, Carmelized, Puree, Summer Yum, & Talk Derby To Me.

I don't have the Too Faced Sweet Peach Eyeshadow Palette at the moment. Just wasn't using it as much to it went to a new home but this COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Peach Punch is definitely pulling shades from this Too faced palette for this one.

Peachy Keen is slightly less peachy compared to Peaches 'n Cream.

Peachini is cooler tone compared to Just Peachy.

Main Peach is a more matte compared to Tempting. 

Public Peach is paler compared to Candied Peach. Both shades are slightly sheer.

Peach Sangria is a slightly paler compared to Luscious.

Georgia Dreams is really close to Peach Pit.

Grilled Peach is also really close compared to Carmelized.
Raspberry Peach is slightly cooler-toned compared to Puree.

Verdict:

Definitely dupes of the Too Faced Sweet Peach with Peach Punch & Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance with Sunset. The shadows are really nicely pigmented and still slightly powdery like the other CoverGirl palettes. I think that if you like to pop of colours in the Anastasia Beverly Hills Modern Renaissance are may just want those the COVERGIRL TruNaked Eye Shadow Palette in Sunsets will definitely fill that need for yours. The Peach Punch although goo is kind of boring considering there is only 2 pop of colour and a lot of generic brown tones in that palette.

But these palettes are lovely and great budget options. Me personally I'm still happy with my Modern Renaissance palette because all the shades work for me. ;)