Dare to Compare: NEW Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn with light Pink and Coral Lipstick shades (bareMinerals, ColourPop, Maybelline, NYX, & MAC) : Swatches & Review

PURCHASED / AFFILIATE LINKS

 Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy.
 Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies.

This post is a review of the New Urban Decay VICE lipsticks I recently picked up, but also a cross-section of different light Pink and Light Coral lipsticks from the drugstore and mid-high end brands. I'm a sucker for light shades because I'm so fair that are not Nude/Flesh tones and make me look sickly. ;)

This post covers products from:

The Urban Decay Vice lipstick retails for  $17US or $21CAN for 3.4 g/ 0.11oz of product.
The bareMinerals Marvelous Moxie lipstick retails for  $19US or $23CAN for 0.12oz of product at full size.
The NYX Butter lipstick retails for  $7.99US or $6.99 CAN for 4.6 g / 0.16 oz  of product.
The Maybelline Color Sensational lipstick retails for  $7.99US or $6.99 CAN for 4.25 g/ 0.15oz of product.
The MAC lipstick retails for  $19US or $23CAN for 3g/ 0.11oz of product.
The ColourPop Lippie Stix retails for  $5US for 1 g/ 0.0352 oz of product.

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn

Urban Decay Vice lipstick box art.

Urban Decay Vice lipstick ingredients.

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn

Urban Decay Vice lipstick in Weirdo

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks new vs old packaging

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks packing compared the LE Alice through the looking glass tube.

Products:
Theis lipsticks I picked up come in two formulas.

The Creme formula of Weirdo is a smooth to apply and creamy texture that doesn't migrate on the lips. It was also very slightly hydration on the lips as well.

The Comfort Matte formula does tug slightly at the lips as you apply this shade, so I recommend going in with a lips brush to get a clean line. But the formula is smooth in texture and doesn't feel drying at all to me. This shade is also very opaque so really only need a thin layer to get the coverage you want. I found that this Unicorn shade does shift in colour and deepens slightly as it dries down on the lips.

Colour: 
Weirdo is a light warm pink with a cream finish
Unicorn is a pale coral pink with a creme matte finish.

Wear:
I got 6 hours wear time with the creme formula before noticing any fading. And 8-9 hours wear with the comfort matte formula.

Packaging: Basic twist-up bullet lipsticks. The new Vice lipstick bullet base it shaped like a Shot Gun shell bullet jacket. This was Heavier than the LE Alice Through the Looking Glass packaging but much lighter in weight compared to the Original Urban Decay lipsticks. The cap of the new VICE lipstick had the same textured gunmetal finish as the original packaging but it also much lighter in weight as well.

NOTE: this post contains the original 1996 vintage bullet case packaging. I have never seen the original products so it's cool the new lipsticks mimic this old packaging.
http://ideefixemon.blogspot.ca/2012/03/vintage-urbay-decay.html

Daylight & Flash Swatches:  Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo and Unicorn

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Weirdo

Urban Decay Vice lipsticks in Unicorn

Compare Light Pink shades:

Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy. 

Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy.  

Products & Colour Compared to Weirdo: 

The bareMinerals Marvelous Moxie lipstick in Speak Your Mind is a rosy light pink with a warm base but it read cooler compared to Weirdo. It also as a similar formula to the VICE creme lipstick.

The Urban Decay Vice lipstick Naked is a deeper and dustier version of the shade Weirdo with the same creme formula.

The Maybelline Color Sensational lipstick in Peach Poppy is a sheerer and lighter and vibrant pink coral compared to Weirdo. But on my lips, this shade cools down to blend with my natural lip colour for a closer match.

The NYX Butter lipstick in Candy Buttons is a sheer glossy cream formula with a warmer orange lean to the shade compared to Weirdo. On the lips, it looks like a brighter shade of pink.

Daylight swatches: Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy. 

Flash Swatches: Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy. 

bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo on the left side of the lip.

Urban Decay in Naked on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo on the left side of the lip.

NYX Butter in Candy Buttons on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo on the left side of the lip.

Maybelline Peach Poppy on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo on the left side of the lip.

Compare Light Coral shades:

Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies. 

Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies.

Urban Decay Vice in Weirdo, bareMinerals Moxie in Speak Your Mind, Urban Decay in Naked, NYX Butter in Candy Buttons, and Maybelline Peach Poppy. Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies.

Products & Colour Compared to Unicorn:
The MAC lipstick in Ever Hip is a sheerer formula which makes the shade lean darker compared to Unicorn on the lips.

The ColourPop Lippie Stix in Caked is a brighter and more vibrant compare to Unicorn with a similar cream matte texture but is a touch more glossy.

The ColourPop Lippie Stix in Button is a deeper version of Unicorn with a similar cream matte texture that is slightly glossy.

The NYX Butter lipstick in Lollies is a sheer glossy cream formula with a paler orange lean to the shade compared to Unicorn. But my lip colour shows through so it makes it look pinker on the lips.

Daylight swatches: Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies.

Flash Swatches: Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, MAC Every Hip , ColourPop Cake and Button , NYX Butter in Lollies.

 MAC Every Hip on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, on the left side of the lip.

ColourPop Cake on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, on the left side of the lip.

ColourPop Button on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, on the left side of the lip.

NYX Butter in Lollies on the right side of the lip and to Urban Decay Vice in Unicorn, on the left side of the lip.

WINNER:
Can I say all of them again? But in all to seriousness, I'm love the new Vice lipstick formulas from Urban Decay as the nicest one to work with, followed by these ColourPop Lippie Stix's.